Quick answer
A Texas conviction can be challenged through three distinct post-trial paths: a motion for new trial (filed within 30 days of sentence), a direct appeal to a Court of Appeals (notice of appeal filed within 30 days), and a writ of habeas corpus (filed in the trial court). Each has different deadlines, different grounds, and different remedies. Strict deadlines apply — missing one can permanently waive the right to relief.
Most clients do not think about appeals until after a conviction — but the seeds of an appeal are planted at trial. Objections preserved on the record, evidence offered and excluded, motions denied — these are the materials an appellate lawyer works with. We routinely consult on trial strategy with appellate preservation in mind, even when we did not handle the trial.
What's on this page
The three post-conviction paths
| Path | Filing window | Grounds | Where filed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Motion for New Trial | 30 days from sentence | Errors in trial proceedings; newly discovered evidence; jury misconduct; ineffective assistance | Trial court |
| Direct Appeal | Notice of appeal within 30 days of sentence (90 if motion for new trial filed) | Errors of law preserved at trial | Texas Court of Appeals (one of 14 districts) |
| Article 11.07 Habeas (felony) | After direct appeal exhausted; effectively unlimited time | Constitutional violations; ineffective assistance; newly discovered evidence; jurisdictional defects | Trial court → Texas Court of Criminal Appeals |
| Article 11.072 Habeas (community supervision) | While on probation | Same as 11.07 — for people not in custody but on probation | Trial court → Texas Court of Criminal Appeals |
The right path depends on the basis for the challenge and where you are in the timeline. Missed deadlines often cannot be cured.
Motion for New Trial — the 30-day window
Under Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 21, a Motion for New Trial must be filed within 30 days after the date sentence is imposed or suspended in open court. Grounds include:
- Jury misconduct — outside influence on the jury, communications between jurors and outsiders, juror dishonesty in voir dire
- Newly discovered evidence — evidence not known and not discoverable with due diligence before trial, that probably would have produced a different result
- Improper jury argument by the prosecutor
- Trial-court error that warrants a new trial
- Ineffective assistance of counsel — often raised in motions for new trial when post-conviction counsel is different from trial counsel
The trial court has 75 days from sentence to rule on the motion. If not ruled on within 75 days, the motion is "overruled by operation of law." Filing a motion for new trial extends the deadline for notice of appeal to 90 days (otherwise 30).
This is the most often missed opportunity in Texas criminal appeals — many defendants do not realize the 30-day clock starts the day of sentencing and runs even if they did not yet have appellate counsel.
Direct appeal — the appellate process
The direct appeal process:
- Notice of Appeal filed in the trial court within 30 days of sentence (90 days if MNT filed).
- Reporter's Record (transcript) ordered from the court reporter. This is the verbatim transcript of trial proceedings.
- Clerk's Record assembled by the trial court clerk — all filed documents, jury instructions, indictment, etc.
- Appellant's Brief filed in the Court of Appeals — typically within 30 days of records being filed, often extended.
- State's Brief in response.
- Reply Brief (optional, by the defendant).
- Oral argument at the Court of Appeals (often requested, not always granted).
- Opinion issued by the Court of Appeals.
- Petition for Discretionary Review (PDR) to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals if the Court of Appeals affirms — discretionary, granted in ~5% of cases.
Texas has 14 Courts of Appeals covering different geographic districts. DFW falls under the Fifth (Dallas), Sixth (Texarkana), Second (Fort Worth), or Tenth (Waco) depending on county. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals (TCCA) sits in Austin and is the highest court for criminal matters in Texas (separate from the Texas Supreme Court, which handles civil matters).
Habeas corpus — collateral attack on the conviction
Habeas corpus is the post-conviction remedy for constitutional violations that cannot be raised on direct appeal — typically because they depend on facts outside the trial record. Texas has two main habeas paths for criminal convictions:
- Article 11.07 (felony convictions, defendant in custody or on parole)
- The petition is filed in the original trial court. The trial court can hold evidentiary hearings, develop facts, and recommend disposition. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals makes the final decision. Most habeas applications are denied without hearing; granted relief is rare but meaningful.
- Article 11.072 (defendant on community supervision)
- The petition is filed in the original trial court. The trial court rules directly. Used by defendants on probation who want to challenge their convictions.
Habeas is most useful for raising claims that depend on extra-record evidence — ineffective assistance of counsel (requires affidavits), Brady violations (requires extra-record proof of suppression), newly discovered evidence, jurisdictional defects, or actual innocence.
Federal habeas under 28 U.S.C. §2254 is available after Texas state remedies are exhausted, but the AEDPA standard of review is highly deferential to state-court decisions, and federal habeas grants relief in only a small fraction of cases.
Common grounds for appellate or habeas relief
- Insufficient evidence: The State did not prove an essential element of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt. Reviewed under Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307 (1979).
- Ineffective assistance of counsel: Trial counsel's performance fell below objective standards and prejudiced the defendant. Reviewed under Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (1984).
- Erroneous suppression rulings: The trial court denied a motion to suppress that should have been granted.
- Improper jury instructions: Failure to give a required charge or giving an erroneous one.
- Improper exclusion of defense evidence: Often involves Rule 412, 803 hearsay rulings, or expert testimony exclusion.
- Improper admission of evidence: Rule 404(b) extraneous offense, Rule 403 balancing, hearsay.
- Prosecutorial misconduct: Improper jury argument, withholding Brady material, knowing use of false testimony.
- Brady violations: Material exculpatory evidence withheld by the State.
- Newly discovered evidence: Including actual-innocence claims supported by DNA, recantation, or alternative-perpetrator evidence.
- Sentencing error: Sentence outside the statutory range, deadly-weapon finding without notice, improper enhancement use.
Realistic odds and what success looks like
Texas criminal appeals affirm the trial court in approximately 70-80% of cases. Reversals usually result in remand for a new trial, not outright acquittal. Habeas applications are denied without hearing in the majority of cases.
That said, "success" in an appeal often means more than reversal. We have seen direct appeals that produced:
- Outright reversal and dismissal (rare but real)
- Reversal with remand for new trial (more common in reversed cases)
- Modification of judgment (incorrect deadly-weapon finding removed, sentence reduced, etc.)
- Affirmance but with a strong concurrence or dissent that supports later habeas relief
- Settlement or PR-based offers from the State while the appeal is pending
And in habeas: most relief comes from ineffective-assistance claims supported by affidavits showing prejudice. Newly discovered evidence claims have a high burden but produce some of the most meaningful exonerations.
If your case is at this stage, do not wait for the State to make the next move.
Call (972) 370-5060Email UsKey Texas terms
- Texas Court of Criminal Appeals (TCCA)
- The highest court in Texas for criminal matters. Sits in Austin. Hears discretionary appeals from Courts of Appeals and original habeas applications under Articles 11.07 and 11.072.
- AEDPA
- Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996. Federal habeas standard requiring deference to state-court decisions; significant restriction on federal habeas relief.
- Strickland standard
- The two-prong test for ineffective assistance of counsel from Strickland v. Washington — deficient performance and resulting prejudice.
- Petition for Discretionary Review (PDR)
- The mechanism for asking the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to review a Court of Appeals decision. Granted in approximately 5% of cases.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to file a notice of appeal in Texas?
30 days from the date sentence is imposed or suspended in open court. If you file a motion for new trial within those 30 days, the notice-of-appeal deadline extends to 90 days. Missing the deadline almost always permanently waives the right to appeal — though late filings can sometimes be raised by habeas claim of ineffective assistance.
Can I appeal a guilty plea in Texas?
Limited grounds. Under Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 25.2(a)(2), you can only appeal pretrial rulings (typically suppression rulings preserved with proper notice) or matters with the trial court's permission. Plea-bargained convictions have additional restrictions. We can review your judgment and certification of right to appeal to see what is available.
How long does a Texas criminal appeal take?
Direct appeals typically take 12-24 months from notice of appeal to opinion. Complex cases or remanded cases can take longer. PDR review at the TCCA adds 6-18 months if granted.
Can I stay out of prison while my appeal is pending?
For some sentences, appellate bond is available. Misdemeanor convictions and probationary sentences are usually appeal-eligible for bond. Felony sentences of 10+ years and convictions for "3g" offenses generally make appellate bond unavailable. The trial court rules on the bond first, then the Court of Appeals can review.
What is the difference between an appeal and habeas corpus?
Direct appeal challenges errors of law preserved at trial, based on the trial record. Habeas corpus challenges constitutional violations, often based on evidence outside the record (affidavits, DNA, new science). Different deadlines, different procedures, different standards of review.
Can I file a habeas petition pro se?
Legally yes, but practically inadvisable. Habeas petitions have strict requirements, complex factual development, and limited do-overs (Texas applies abuse-of-the-writ doctrine to bar repeat petitions). Most successful habeas relief comes from petitions filed by experienced counsel with affidavits and evidentiary support.
If my appeal succeeds, will I be released?
Not necessarily. Most reversals result in remand for new trial, not outright dismissal. After remand, the State may retry, plea, or dismiss depending on its assessment. In a small number of cases — typically sufficiency reversals or speedy-trial violations — reversal results in outright acquittal or dismissal that bars retrial.
Related stages
About the Authors
