An allegation about missing government files poses a different question from an allegation about a false entry. A new Arkansas bar-examination case brings both into view. For Texas public employees and records custodians, the useful distinction is between authorized disposal and an act that unlawfully makes an official record unavailable. The answer requires the actual record, applicable rules, and evidence of what happened.

What Arkansas officials announced

On November 5, 2026, the Arkansas Supreme Court announced criminal charges against former Office of Professional Programs executive director Nancie Givens. Its releases describe 65 counts of tampering with a public record involving alleged bar-exam score discrepancies. A joint statement also describes alleged file deletion intended to conceal misconduct. These are allegations; Givens is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. Read the joint statement and the court's separate announcement.

The joint statement says most examinees previously told they passed did pass. It describes an ongoing review, not a finding against every examinee or lawyer. This article has not reviewed the charging instruments or underlying computer evidence. It does not infer who benefited knowingly or determine anyone's admission status. The Texas discussion below is a separate comparison, not an application of Texas law to the Arkansas defendant.

Separate the record from the action

Texas Penal Code Section 37.01 defines governmental records broadly, including information belonging to, received by, or kept by government. Section 37.10(a)(3) addresses intentional destruction, concealment, removal, or other impairment of a governmental record's truthfulness, readability, or availability. Subsection (b) provides an exception for legally authorized destruction or specified transfers. False entries and knowing use of false records appear in separate subsections. Read Sections 37.01 and 37.10.

Start a review with a record map. Identify the file alleged to be missing, the office that kept it, its purpose, and the location from which it disappeared. Ask whether the allegation concerns an original record, a working copy, an exported report, or several different items. Those descriptions should be supported by evidence rather than assumed from a filename.

Next, describe the alleged action precisely. A changed score, removed attachment, inaccessible mailbox, and discarded paper folder are different events. A broad accusation that someone “deleted the records” can hide important factual disagreements. Counsel needs the particular act attributed to the person and the evidence connecting that person to it.

A retention period is only part of the inquiry

For local-government records, Texas Local Government Code Section 202.001 identifies authorized destruction routes, including a valid records control schedule with applicable retention or compliant storage conditions. Section 202.002 restricts destruction where the custodian knows the subject matter is in litigation; pending public-information requests also receive protection. Read Chapter 202. These local-government provisions should not be silently substituted for the rules governing a state agency or another institution.

For a particular DFW office, ask for the policy and schedule actually applicable when the event occurred. Record the issuing authority, effective version, record category, and any approval documentation. A general internet search for “how long to keep email” cannot establish permission to destroy a specific file. An employee's recollection that a supervisor approved cleanup needs to be checked against the actual instruction and its scope.

The Texas State Library and Archives Commission's Local Schedule GR explains that electronic records must remain accessible for their required retention period. It distinguishes official records from convenience copies and warns that litigation, audits, public-information requests, and other pending actions can prevent destruction after a retention period expires. Read the schedule's introduction and retention notes. Those instructions make the record's function and any pending matter important parts of the review.

Build a chronology that can be checked

A useful chronology places the alleged loss beside the surrounding administrative events. Include the date of any migration, account closure, scheduled disposal, preservation instruction, audit notice, and discovery of the missing material. Identify where each date came from. An email sent on one day and received or read on another should not be collapsed into a single assumed event.

Question for reviewMaterial to identifyInference to avoid
What was the record?Original location, record category, and relevant versionsA filename alone proves its contents or legal status
What authority applied?Contemporaneous schedule, policy, and disposal approvalAge alone established permission
Who performed the action?Access records and evidence explaining account useAn account label alone identifies the human actor
What remained available?Documented copies, archives, and recovery findingsA search failure proves permanent destruction

This is a framework for asking questions, not a claim about evidence in the Arkansas case. Mark unknown items as unknown. If an office has only a summary from a technology vendor, distinguish that summary from the underlying records and ask what the vendor actually examined.

Recovery and responsibility are separate questions

When a file cannot be found, record the search that produced that conclusion: which system, which account, what date range, and who conducted it. If a later recovery locates a copy, preserve the recovery report too. Both observations can matter. Neither should be rewritten to make the chronology appear simpler.

Discuss any proposed recovery with counsel and an authorized technology professional. Preserve the current system state and existing reports; do not run cleanup tools, change access permissions, or test deletion behavior on the disputed material while trying to explain what happened. An improvised experiment can introduce new changes and make the original sequence harder to evaluate.

Access, authority, and intent also need separate attention. Someone may administer a system without deciding what the office may discard. Someone who approves a disposal may not perform it. A careful consultation identifies each person's role and avoids treating an organizational title as proof of an individual act.

Prepare for a Texas consultation without exposing other people's files

Public offices may hold applications, addresses, identification documents, or confidential correspondence. Do not post those materials online to answer a news story or workplace accusation. Begin with an index describing the records and where they are held. Arrange an authorized, secure review rather than forwarding an entire office archive to a personal account.

Bring the notice of investigation or charge, any relevant employment instructions, and the available record-management documents. Identify deadlines and requests already received. Explain which records you control and which belong to someone else. Counsel can then determine what additional material to request and how to obtain it properly.

L&L Law Group discusses Texas criminal-defense matters at (972) 370-5060 or info@landllawgroup.com. The office is at 5899 Preston Road, Suite 101, Frisco, Texas 75034. No outcome is promised. Illustration: the courtroom, scales, and gavel are symbolic; they do not depict the Arkansas office, defendant, or case evidence.

Frequently asked questions

Do the Arkansas announcements establish guilt?

No. They announce charges and describe allegations and an ongoing review. They are not a conviction.

Does this article suggest every Arkansas examinee had an incorrect result?

No. The joint statement says most people previously informed they passed did pass. Individual status should be confirmed through the responsible authorities.

Is Texas governmental-record tampering limited to false statements?

No. Section 37.10 separately addresses several actions, including intentional impairment of a record under subsection (a)(3).

Does reaching a retention date automatically authorize disposal?

No. The applicable schedule, authorization, and any restriction on destruction must be examined. Local-government litigation and public-information-request rules may prevent disposal.

Does an unavailable file establish who deleted it?

Not by itself. Ask what was searched, which systems were examined, and what evidence identifies the person responsible.

Should I repair or reorganize disputed files before speaking with counsel?

Preserve their current state and obtain advice before making changes. Provide a clear index and explain any missing information rather than recreating records from memory.

Prepared with ChatGPT assistance for L&L Law Group. Sources checked November 9, 2026. General information only; no personal attorney review of the generated text is claimed. Reading this page does not create an attorney-client relationship.